Development of a New Ramus Anterior Vertical Reference Line for the Evaluation of Skeletal and Dental Changes as a Decision Aid for the Treatment of Crowding in the Lower Jaw: Extraction vs. Nonextraction

Objectives: Anterior crowding in the lower jaw is a common orthodontic issue often managed through premolar extraction, which can affect facial profile development. This study aimed to evaluate skeletal and dental changes in moderate to severe crowding using a novel mandibular reference line-the Ramus Anterior Vertical (RaV)-to support treatment planning. Methods: A total of 140 patients (LII > 4 mm and < 9 mm; mean age ≈ 12.5 years) were divided into two groups (G1: extraction; G2: nonextraction; total n = 140; n = 70 per group). Skeletal and dental parameters were measured before (T0) and after (T1) orthodontic treatment using 280 lateral cephalograms. RaV was defined as a vertical line through the anterior ramus point, perpendicular to the occlusal plane. Results: Sagittal measurements relative to RaV were reproducible and unaffected by mandibular mobility. Significant vertical skeletal changes were observed in G2 females, with an increased anterior facial height (N-Sp' and Sp'-Gn) but a stable Hasund Index. In G1, the dental arch length and distances from RaV to i5 and i6 were reduced, while second molars (i7) remained stable. Sagittal incisor axis changes (L1-NB°, SAi1°) and skeletal-dental correlations (ML-NSL, Gn-tGo-Ar) were present only in G1. Conclusions: RaV proved to be a stable mandibular reference for assessing treatment effects. In this study, premolar extraction vs. nonextraction was comparably effective, though some vertical skeletal adaptations, especially in G2 females, took place.